When it comes to Italian dining in Canada, two names always come up: Scaddabush and East Side Mario’s. Both offer bold flavors, generous portions, and that cozy Italian hospitality we all love. But if you had to pick just one where should you spend your money and appetite?
Let’s break down the battle between Scaddabush Menu and East Side Mario’s Menu to find out who really has the better Italian menu.
Visit here Who Has the Better Menu?
Atmosphere & Experience
- Scaddabush: Stylish and modern with a trendy urban vibe. Perfect for date nights or Instagram-worthy pasta shots. The open kitchen and mozzarella bar add a touch of showmanship to your meal.
- East Side Mario’s: Casual, fun, and family-friendly. Known for its loud, cheerful atmosphere and endless garlic bread. A nostalgic favorite for many Canadians.
Verdict: East Side Mario’s wins for relaxed dining. Scaddabush wins for modern flair.
Menu Variety
- Scaddabush: Fresh hand-pulled mozzarella, house-made pasta, gourmet pizzas, and signature cocktails.
- East Side Mario’s: Classic Italian pasta, all-you-can-eat soup/salad, and fun Canadian-Italian combos.
Verdict: Scaddabush for foodies. East Side Mario’s for comfort and variety.
Price & Value
- Scaddabush: $25–$35 per pasta dish; more premium, upscale pricing.
- East Side Mario’s: Budget-friendly combo deals, lunch specials, and frequent promotions.
Verdict: East Side Mario’s wins for value. Scaddabush is a special-occasion spot.
Standout Dishes
Scaddabush Favorites:
- Chicken & Lemon Ricotta Pappardelle
- Roasted Mushroom & Truffle Gnocchi
- Balsamic Truffle Mozzarella
- Zeppole Donuts
East Side Mario’s Must-Trys:
- Mario’s Spaghetti & Meatballs
- Chicken Parmigiana
- Hell’s Kitchen Chicken Penne
- Budda Boomers
Drinks & Extras
Scaddabush: Elegant cocktails, wine pairings, and happy hour vibes.
East Side Mario’s: Classic sodas, family drinks, and fun frozen mocktails.
Final Verdict: It Depends On What You Crave
Choose Scaddabush if you're into modern Italian dishes, handcrafted mozzarella, and elevated ambiance.
Choose East Side Mario’s if you want comfort food, generous portions, and affordable dining for the whole family.
Both serve up delicious plates of Italian goodness—but the best part? You can try both, because there’s always room for pasta!
Conclusion
Whether you're in the mood for handcrafted Italian with a modern twist at Scaddabush or hearty, feel-good favorites at East Side Mario’s, you can’t really go wrong. Both restaurants offer something unique: Scaddabush excels in presentation and creativity, while East Side Mario’s delivers comfort, value, and consistency. Your choice depends on the occasion, your budget, and your appetite for adventure. So why not try both and let your taste buds be the judge?
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Which restaurant is more budget-friendly?
A: East Side Mario’s offers better value for families and larger groups with all-you-can-eat options and combo deals.
Q: Does Scaddabush make their food fresh?
A: Yes, Scaddabush is known for making fresh mozzarella daily and offering chef-driven, modern Italian cuisine.
Q: Are there vegetarian or vegan options?
A: Both restaurants have vegetarian options, but Scaddabush typically has more modern plant-based dishes on the menu.
Q: Can I book reservations at either location?
A: Yes, both restaurants allow online reservations depending on availability and location.
Q: Which is better for a casual date night?
A: Scaddabush offers a more upscale, trendy setting ideal for dates, while East Side Mario’s is better for casual family dinners.